Upper Iowa boasts 52 NSIC All-Academic honorees from their fall sports. There were 33 Peacocks that earned NSIC All-Academic Team of Excellence honors and 19 more that earned NSIC All-Academic Team honors.
 
In total, the Northern Sun Conference recognized 864 student-athletes across their 16 institutions with 535 earning NSIC All-Academic Team of Excellence honors and 329 grabbing NSIC All-Academic recognition.

To be eligible for the NSIC All-Academic Team of Excellence, a student-athlete must have a 3.60 cumulative GPA or higher, while NSIC All-Academic Team members must have a cumulative GPA between 3.20 and 3.59. 
 
Additionally, the student-athlete must be a member of the varsity traveling team and in at least their second year of competition at their current institution (true freshmen, red-shirt freshmen and ineligible athletic transfers are not eligible). Furthermore, the student-athlete must have completed at least one full academic year at their current institution (student must be in at least their 3rd academic-year-semester at their institution).

All five of Upper Iowa's fall sports sponsored by the NSIC garnered all-academic honors; including 20 from football, 14 from volleyball, 10 from women's soccer, and four each from the women and men's cross country teams.

Below is the full list of UIU student-athletes selected for the teams; those marked with an asterisk (*) were named to the NSIC All-Academic Team of Excellence.

Football (20):  * Eddy Gosche (5th - Schaumburg, Ill.), * Collin Jones (Jr. - Oshkosh, Wis.), * Brady Stevens (So. - Sun Prairie, Wis.), * Baxter Bohr (So. - Swisher, Iowa), * RJ Knaack (Sr. - Kaukauna, Wis.), * Connor Andresen (So. - Anamosa, Iowa), * Traegen Kramer (So. - Le Mars, Iowa), * Connor Frasier (Jr. - McFarland, Wis.), * Hunter Brooks (So. - Joliet, Ill.), * Marcus Orr (So. - Mount Vernon, Iowa), * Ben Houselog (So. - North Liberty, Iowa), * Kenneth Draeving (Jr. - Beloit, Wis.), * Drake Kinney (So. - Cedar Rapids, Iowa), Tyler Owen (So. - Madison, Wis.), Jacob Seeger (So. - Kenosha, Wis.), Rhett Smith (So. - Wapello, Iowa), Zachary Hamilton (So. - Milwaukee, Wis.), Noah Schirmers (Jr. - Blaine, Minn.), Jacob Daniel (5th - Chandlerville, Ill.), Peyton Bieber (Sr. - Waukon, Iowa).

Volleyball (14):  * Emily Kono (Jr. - Center Point, Iowa), * Martha Pace (So. - West Liberty, Iowa), * Sarah Johnson (Sr. - Elk River, Minn.), * Madelyn Rettler (Jr. - West Bend, Wis.), * Sarah Stevelinck (Grad. - Lyons, Colo.), * Kylie Willis (Sr. - Grundy Center, Iowa), * Carlee Dove (Sr. - New Hartford, Iowa), * Kaci Beesecker (Jr. - Fairbank, Iowa), * Kaitlyn Mohwinkle (Grad. - Aplington, Iowa), * Maggie Streightiff (Grad. - Hayfield, Minn.), Zoe Semelroth (Jr. - Tripoli, Iowa), Kylee Oldenburger (Jr. - Cedar Rapids, Iowa), Kayla Veto (Jr. - Moline, Ill.), Nicole Pozorski (Jr. - Eagle, Wis.).

Women's Soccer (10):  * Alena Miller (Jr. - Forest Lake, Minn.), * Katie Samuels (R-Sr. - Blackburn, United Kingdom), * Grace Birdsley (Sr. - Prior Lake, Minn.), * Katrina Kazluski (So. - Poplar Grove, Ill.), * Haley Ramberg (Grad. - St. Francis, Minn.), Nora Nouhaili (R-So. - Las Vegas, Nev.), Toni Powsey (Grad. - Cumberland, BC, Canada), Alex Garcia (So. - Barcelona, Spain), Chloe Jarosz (So. - Omaha, Neb.), Leah Willenbring (Sr. - South St. Paul, Minn.).

Women's Cross Country (4):  * Ashley Donovan (Sr. - Dubuque, Iowa), * Delaney Miller (Jr. - Chandler, Ariz.), * Jadyn Schultz (Jr. - Independence, Iowa), Macey White (Grad. - Mount Pleasant, Iowa).

Men's Cross Country (4): * Bryce Baker (Jr. - Rochester, Minn.), * Nathan Goranson (Jr. - Greeley, Iowa), Brady Johnston (Jr. - Platteville, Wis.), David Snider (Sr. - Havana, Ill.)